{ "study": "exposure-control-v1", "evidence_kind": "executed_mock_traffic_simulation", "deployment_authorized": false, "windows": [ { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "shadow", "percent": 0, "revision": 0, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 0, "used_windows": [], "used_artifacts": [], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-1", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 0, "start": 0, "end": 10, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 10, "artifact_id": "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "canary", "percent": 5, "revision": 1, "healthy_windows": 1, "last_end": 10, "used_windows": [ "window-1" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "simulation_healthy_window", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": false, "served_candidate": 0, "served_baseline": 40, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.14750001719221473, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08650001836940646, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.12241699732840061, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06125000072643161, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06399996345862746, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06175000453367829, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05791697185486555, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05470798350870609, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06341701373457909, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.058500037994235754, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0570000265724957, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05645799683406949, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057958008255809546, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07220800034701824, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05479104584082961, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060999998822808266, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05299999611452222, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053374969866126776, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05566701292991638, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0524159986525774, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05483400309458375, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05204201443120837, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0600829953327775, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05541701102629304, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0705840066075325, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05424994742497802, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05625002086162567, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05299999611452222, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054791977163404226, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05554204108193517, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05437503568828106, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05337502807378769, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05520897684618831, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05383399548009038, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057582976296544075, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07337500574067235, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057958008255809546, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05345797399058938, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05441700341179967, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054540985729545355, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.055999960750341415, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05324999801814556, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054500007536262274, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05404202966019511, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06104202475398779, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05179201252758503, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07566704880446196, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05541602149605751, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05445902934297919, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05820801015943289, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.056374992709606886, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052333984058350325, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05612499080598354, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052374962251633406, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05720800254493952, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05429197335615754, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054500007536262274, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07662497228011489, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07870799163356423, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0576250022277236, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05612499080598354, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06775005022063851, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06524997297674417, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05787500413134694, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060999998822808266, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.055916025303304195, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053916010074317455, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05224999040365219, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06816600216552615, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06029102951288223, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07791694952175021, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05891697946935892, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06366596790030599, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052791961934417486, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054500007536262274, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06129202665761113, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05691696424037218, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05179201252758503, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06916699931025505, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-1-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06066705100238323, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "canary", "percent": 5, "revision": 1, "healthy_windows": 1, "last_end": 10, "used_windows": [ "window-1" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-2", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 1, "start": 10, "end": 20, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 20, "artifact_id": "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 20, "artifact_id": "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 20, "artifact_id": "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 20, "artifact_id": "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "expanded", "percent": 25, "revision": 2, "healthy_windows": 2, "last_end": 20, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "simulation_healthy_window", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": false, "served_candidate": 4, "served_baseline": 36, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08579203858971596, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06308301817625761, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.12862501898780465, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07837498560547829, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06849999772384763, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06695801857858896, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06487499922513962, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06883300375193357, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08550001075491309, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05712499842047691, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06379198748618364, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06112497067078948, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05870801396667957, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053709023632109165, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053499999921768904, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052749994210898876, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05608401261270046, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052916991990059614, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06879196735098958, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0574590521864593, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05866703577339649, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057500030379742384, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05387497367337346, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05929195322096348, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053333002142608166, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05324999801814556, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05779101047664881, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05379202775657177, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05241698818281293, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06699998630210757, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07104198448359966, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05549995694309473, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05208398215472698, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053875031881034374, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053916010074317455, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05529099144041538, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05416700150817633, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05770899588242173, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053916999604552984, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.059999991208314896, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06970902904868126, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05620799493044615, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05316600436344743, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-2-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05266600055620074, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:d8f5391d0052f06c35439403f66224d19749c26d016a0f9eb148d2a50aa1e36e", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:60144b8edd91abd7a8bb7ba63f52a0145581768a2da5be02dc66c578a5dfe5df", "sha256:e1166072bf860627c4cca1d299d4138c8211de3909d4761e4441b89857cfa535", "sha256:405eff9952e6d6c221725ed0bc6be9defefbd4000a1a611d281d107483f07c66", "sha256:327b5cd1bcdfd29f516ed99c9861df4b10c1cfc9f47ad52b1596283dbdf01d4b", "sha256:2cb46ee39bd136b64cef249723561e72cf486db54938640e82496b316736a2e9", "sha256:61abc1fd59dcf9b2902e6d39e1b65f27a67c60addd3fc6539beb40d2a466e0e7", "sha256:478d303dd6e5ab4961906a8bee56c1e577c7b6b74f7c15075582bdd125b32314", "sha256:ae241ce612ca44b6612433d3979665939e2dc17647f792dafad09912d077764b", "sha256:82460be4644544c1a41a1ab391b1c0da36bce4721642aeaebfce3003eaea9479", "sha256:31c7321521388a37b84938b9c85e6d8f27b007ab10285b2a881a2eb2856dc5a3", "sha256:b3782954e79fa7e3ccbba36f0f4717aabe00135bf75b76e21878783c1b2097c1", "sha256:733210c48fae343731172993f542c382c52b3b8c623f361dbfbc4611adf51e73", "sha256:7afeca188aa77e7de81e4b3568fb4db224de6eea23f4faa7d6795523d8332df1", "sha256:5c4afcbfad8960c66e4ae3c0eaf8e44a6b0546a3c0bbbc299ef3554417f8c440", "sha256:9fd07b32e362e3e72c656a23da7cc233543ef3750d1f98dcadd6fbb1a4f01e99", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:387ee4cda27f9512ce5395ee9154eba7f6fd3421ef413bcf400e58ec354acd65", "sha256:d8a309b775775d6459360b07936ae7416f58bd57ee5cf69f1381cdf8dac48ae1", "sha256:d3f6e883a00b9a7e8203bd88d19f574b43403785a518504a819e0e917c676aff", "sha256:4d8afa8f5464e3261c9139b6f7eebd9a45fd09fe8072559b1638a72b8e845399", "sha256:e02109c85f97ea8969275451a131ae8bdcaf0502a0a67d26af5fe74750a7883f", "sha256:270429d545a1bb4a15973a73b115e3098bb2af8378ac2fed75fc2ba51af43503", "sha256:23563a908ade1a02a7ab5febaa3717c8a73d882a8926d0258829a0cf23dd741d", "sha256:1c1dfd2ce625a7f822368f3ab06ac1450298fd5f084e8959f506403a3c8811ab", "sha256:1bc99b64dc070029912757e34ad08b2546aeeb15011b35737e417c12728f4d6c", "sha256:ac203024922076771c7499d8c1194fbc01ae6ab5032e2c40773a08dc6e54358f", "sha256:26f3f3b2c1b78fc170ca4e4a965c3d0cdcd7fcbac19f8d3220a5c9517458a156", "sha256:10d9270dd49ca0911348b50f2a97da80b53d5ff64e3e2f27c8ad26f1bc6d18fc", "sha256:5296ac8687c6902cb5782d26c19abf3dcae1b6513e1982256b3c4edc5dcab389", "sha256:1558a1f68a10a5db65e06abb587878d50f4a12f6e968bec29d4ef8dd13a89220", "sha256:a8806e4f17b806f0b09460440c100c23b2da15bd67fa283b0150eaa2b31c1e1a", "sha256:005dac50c9cba1ecbe8d7ab64cdef2de954ad8a6c4d27a6e1235a5611e452822", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:680c33336fd352f110991392832c8994e08719e1782ce4f389e7c1dbefe91e53", "sha256:3edc69514f30e2cd76e9d1c08ac0f55d975c056db1408778fb1d52746949393d", "sha256:c40d36eaa0bc2f26bf00bdcd2592850b35199663199fef64061d0406856db1d0", "sha256:4f17546aa33e21f5912507cb56b268d61c88ad0c152b7fd8e6abe230cdc55865" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "expanded", "percent": 25, "revision": 2, "healthy_windows": 2, "last_end": 20, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-3", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 2, "start": 20, "end": 30, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 30, "artifact_id": "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "restricted", "percent": 5, "revision": 3, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 30, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "illustrative_quality_regression", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": false, "served_candidate": 13, "served_baseline": 27, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0672080204822123, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05983398295938969, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.025874993298202753, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.058790959883481264, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.020749983377754688, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05620898446068168, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05383294774219394, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054750009439885616, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07104198448359966, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057416968047618866, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05466601578518748, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.02041697734966874, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.058542005717754364, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05429197335615754, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060583988670259714, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05345797399058938, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06129202665761113, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053916999604552984, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0515839783474803, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07041700882837176, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054540985729545355, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054917007219046354, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.022499996703118086, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08012499893084168, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366699770092964, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05245796637609601, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05704100476577878, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0226249685510993, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05566602339968085, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.02054101787507534, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05466700531542301, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07254100637510419, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.021208019461482763, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05645799683406949, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05262502236291766, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.020458013750612736, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05624996265396476, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05566695472225547, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06166601087898016, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06929202936589718, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06166700040921569, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05804101238027215, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.025291985366493464, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07287500193342566, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06258400389924645, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.02133403904736042, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06095797289162874, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.021875021047890186, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05870801396667957, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.020708946976810694, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05683302879333496, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [], "output": { "message": "Service unavailable; no refund was issued.", "claimed_outcome": "needs_review", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "unknown", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": null, "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.024582957848906517, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-3-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06087502697482705, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "unavailable" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:77e411bf5b717024fa6e278f7dedd9ca14b4314f4b27f620f7093260e96f8114", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:60e1125d27c3d1dfec97611622ed15b3e26b9bf2c3822d5bf3b1cf0bb50fcf4d", "sha256:1658399d38046ee66b32bb73f303c988c1e487eacd6b1f64ba35c96a529cdeb6", "sha256:352739ae93fd5e96b3412399accf44912c191054718a9e4a8d1e907e5eed6721", "sha256:42d470fb21dabe1d87d51b32ab7b07f6d095bdf55179f2d06e1f77db7be52511", "sha256:416e9d38135c8b24503da72978beb01980c5c72ca13ef4d764be268b3c9d7741", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:50462e64b2584fab1ae2afa055f5d06aea5629e7174691da9cf142f7aeccebcc", "sha256:4ba0c230ecd4ca65e60555843272c56137d257b78e9713a7335b367c696affc9", "sha256:b88bbf860049a10c0e80faa48271a457f1af7d59263b973d6d3f0bb214e4e289", "sha256:eb9a8f85c1767f234bd65bc69fac5c409789236449eae642c7466157126a5607", "sha256:309c0f0efa70aabc1c6a590b47ecb255c536d033cb7a3aa422206026966129f1", "sha256:9b6f482e833d37b39aa3e9a8d08c06c095fdda09225016919583428fa3bab5e8", "sha256:7215a8866d73868d1356c36958d2dfca4e8ec048d836bf5bddeabfa1cf51333c", "sha256:87c39bf19273e1be38e68abcdc7509e180936ed2be9d89b6c69e59616d0fe864", "sha256:eda1d0a26e7b91e65bf0bd3fbaa98edf1f7debbf8053c1184729c86c9b391212", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:e80d826bed6546749e6bce26183b3ba28cd79d740d604d191213fe112900df98", "sha256:6d5603270da3e25ba61a70eb1fcf3537cf7a59d6d7b574d585ed097d1c04c815", "sha256:27066b2fa30daf227c424a81f71d7a16d98885f80e3920cfe5d5c6569e40e46a", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:eea1fded983fca8ff151f842a4e92f557b6f4a83edcad52ddb3a62bc9061d4a6", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:434e433485c3f760083041472f2195d9682471899c4ee4590268c1847e5bcd51", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:24824a9e8a15100f74955300d50c81aa00b8719e852d3e1062e3c3477052403c", "sha256:6b043785922afb2b88a10855ddf56bfc0d8d20e09c003f196a00ed8ffec12a6c", "sha256:b2fdc8ea68b173e6a498a3695a56952a68d1c7f2339c0a9f38e8c655a01d0c35", "sha256:ffd212c2219e4dae03efdb4e8f99c0276c44b11ae9751c5e793db5b95a166d8a", "sha256:ca1dd8d9fddaa4c191644a3ec24b2f3125ba76d802d70f68fbef0a6d6de170ba", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:c8ad7b5b7c80b09783c8c6dd455ff225661c9eb3fb8cd1e5576715d1039eeba0", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:7d27e0803f75de06090af86fe23a5cf5b4e62a3e24f2dc7d5780f098c4faff8b" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "restricted", "percent": 5, "revision": 3, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 30, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-4", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 3, "start": 30, "end": 40, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 40, "artifact_id": "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 40, "artifact_id": "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 40, "artifact_id": "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 40, "artifact_id": "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "restricted", "percent": 5, "revision": 4, "healthy_windows": 1, "last_end": 40, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "simulation_healthy_window", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": false, "served_candidate": 4, "served_baseline": 36, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07104198448359966, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05604198668152094, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07099995855242014, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.058500037994235754, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06370799383148551, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06233301246538758, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05512498319149017, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.055500015150755644, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054791977163404226, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060041958931833506, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05420797970145941, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06045802729204297, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07237499812617898, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06337498780339956, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054709031246602535, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05462497938424349, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366699770092964, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05754095036536455, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05691597471013665, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.058334029745310545, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05337502807378769, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05383399548009038, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05804095417261124, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.2775419852696359, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06354204379022121, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06508297519758344, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05258398596197367, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05904096178710461, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06416701944544911, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05608302308246493, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057582976296544075, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0522919581271708, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06208301056176424, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05254201823845506, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06458396092057228, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05862500984221697, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05579105345532298, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05337502807378769, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05208398215472698, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0534169957973063, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05716603482142091, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05608296487480402, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0634589814580977, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-4-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06208301056176424, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:58ab26f828374383115b903eeeacb78d8200669c056ac83edef47b95bc358670", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:29da12b3a4e191d9bd5cff63d39f1c4e783f4f08376849ce07cd17762c8fbfe9", "sha256:4351f37ab2c0543bad4e31378907fe07c6269c8469a93e377c9c8785dd160b36", "sha256:2a6d5353cd2c8417fcf9f693dbb66e3a507ef5226ccfe95e7d1d1475e994159e", "sha256:882d1541a755606fff0c6945c148dc98fbef4d2e64b573c9c16ae30e200ca6a9", "sha256:cad78ec97ccb8278a3221af8667883c3bd8d622886f28eebafc2cce42069aedc", "sha256:7d910455242021324d132f4b4b98b40587fe53dd7c9d555fbaef9f0a5dbbfeb4", "sha256:2637bedc2956296e819171fe5105cffc96e1d1bca1f0ab27f7c910e2b03c0884", "sha256:71e4a94b487279daa2dbeb371f83ca7178c4feba90082e65eed23db2c158c539", "sha256:220182b90de9f3cdef3d2bdf4ade15b92950a530fb9b075b4a7d1a601a6d1e76", "sha256:f909c11b7eb722a5fcc315ba62fc3f7cc96c51b31d4b7d3fe478fe222878300d", "sha256:eb9c992035965410bad59ccb4933777b61535f82f439d50ee9cffb8a5b7700da", "sha256:888eeaffae387cd72f938be2c9b46477520dc5c7d0addb324a8d3e23831ebcbd", "sha256:21ae124e07e3befd462ddf56994377409737609549066443b2137763787a0114", "sha256:e208f581b4526d403bf78741f0c4eab84172b1ef1961348f4fc7ec45b9243f08", "sha256:1aa2cc81f791536e18b816e6acd3ab713ec6b22d0f8594377ce8bebbe0686c14", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:c1aad6fea452f856338729ac23ca6ab39c18ef62d838293ccf6411ee01a31187", "sha256:55bbe3ab5d383e0118ca06dc2af76c3f1b093b931c315287f1b8f2d45f1f358f", "sha256:82223998aa14e6977dbbb3a4a0e8bf7f55e70f130cfb8eb8128acc8c50722d0e", "sha256:097c90ecc41736da77be08206c1ded511e2152c3ebbf92f31af632ecc48bc339", "sha256:853a7b592a55d3dc947de8f97ac5feb3e60bb77910b467e2ff1045d178273fc9", "sha256:9cf59ac1b24a5e5b400d0db195c1246769e0bb7e7f33aab397bc5a195545116f", "sha256:6a4ef5c5dc8a35168b24223603f98476652f5ec6d0aba14dce66d857feb80c4c", "sha256:0470f70ce854860a78ef3c469dfdd5eacd212de54da1177c9b96344c71c7830d", "sha256:bf39a0f66532f91d83c9862f480ff5e7f178145e12468b45a730e2020a3a3517", "sha256:9731c070945f317045b97be618f638acfeb93dab3f6a24172e124a73cc752664", "sha256:28e678cc8d7701edcbaa1c692afe508f86eabb7c7da5ba34169dfb59f055d164", "sha256:25fba2775edb04e08afd6a294034d17fd5d358b9bda625e9fe2e6e0e88c55918", "sha256:87794b99dc5340434fac444f1c14186a364d6b7cabb95c7e956f0717f150e7f4", "sha256:a1a19d0a0b1341575c09079965a5c6b6c2331180bee9af54079090e374dc854c", "sha256:f1020543ff3dd0675d8af44747e9124c05bb17668c4d08dd8f3fd1fe992b13d6", "sha256:cb58d8fb61b819ea45146bb8629da412911bbc68c71fe9ba796ce7a35bcdec48", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:4dccf675aa2b515ada260c9ca6d3de4216cbd6a8a447fb9501848e4050511561", "sha256:bea5a141a801e97890325c49074601c7a7d27d00559ced126cdf047f8e603d8f", "sha256:aa719196cfb89c9d6eab656a33145566dab1e0e212cda00e08514c8a5d5f8dc9", "sha256:6df68f38bc65d4735c0ffe48faf701d012102b5bd699c71f93eab4dd20ee4bae" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "restricted", "percent": 5, "revision": 4, "healthy_windows": 1, "last_end": 40, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-5", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 4, "start": 40, "end": 50, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 50, "artifact_id": "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 50, "artifact_id": "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 50, "artifact_id": "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": true, "hard_violation": false, "mature_at": 50, "artifact_id": "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "canary", "percent": 5, "revision": 5, "healthy_windows": 2, "last_end": 50, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4", "window-5" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "simulation_resume", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": true, "served_candidate": 4, "served_baseline": 36, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08058297680690885, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05816703196614981, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05529198097065091, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05712499842047691, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05245895590633154, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.062417006120085716, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05820801015943289, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05324999801814556, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052292016334831715, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.056917022448033094, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05387497367337346, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06516597932204604, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.056416960433125496, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05400000372901559, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05195901030674577, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05179201252758503, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05520804552361369, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05254201823845506, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05191704258322716, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05620898446068168, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05395803600549698, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05458400119096041, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07208297029137611, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05429098382592201, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.051749986596405506, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05191704258322716, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05983398295938969, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366699770092964, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05158403655514121, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05283398786559701, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05299999611452222, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05195901030674577, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06445898907259107, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05770899588242173, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05241698818281293, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.051875016652047634, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053750001825392246, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06187497638165951, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05108397454023361, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.055541982874274254, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054750009439885616, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05933298962190747, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06024999311193824, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-5-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07058301707729697, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:faf2bd187b0317f69c862265c767e913fd1f2063cf2260310a90c1c3a5b21689", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:fa42e04d6288976efe8e719583c04233f99355765c4fd31dbf3c06483a47a417", "sha256:e10572a47068751ce7d2f64a05cc181a92c0c148f90b21166fdd8f9ce48d0476", "sha256:38eb1f010ce45627c0d9cd56833c16c51cc77a1b29292981171ceb5a3a7aaf3e", "sha256:eb045e59a31a5813781ee4caf7f410cb88ebee05fec07430a502ca36984a14ab", "sha256:ee48ee5fea10e93c81ea04a4ea3c3e6e916b22f4a924d7febdf19009f958fc77", "sha256:be3869d6feab3ebb304d4a62ca07b35abe70bdb0f74bda2e972716f96dedb719", "sha256:e7611df23cb7fbe984a6f23b5cc7277ab1dc42d692f4f5c551fb4e20213a9180", "sha256:d8b471ddb1c721b67db78a1257c865939bfea01b1f4b88f93efa738a94a713d6", "sha256:c3947357ce0664e8c3d795ca9612d275d63c0415fc9530d68b5ff47deba025a1", "sha256:a99c51678144fa4b3f019b9085cf24c9ab430606d61067d1686cdf1c67054eb3", "sha256:66b0a77444547a8885fc77c179423603883e436ab46cf8cb4cf8ab913ad4be21", "sha256:dbd70a5e530630290738ef16cad8cbdf7bd34242dd00313b9094d12568cb545f", "sha256:7b04fd884430c9343c0b2538eaeea773400eee71b63bc22535fc2b4e4ef7e550", "sha256:e83f7fb2cb47d448baa9534545752067f1a0cf31d88d76867aa659fff699daf6", "sha256:2dc759d8b5a3e68335179d24148ebf9f09bcab57eea13156c72669b6af86b91a", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:bb8995e7612292aa64d8f0cab23c8eebdbce9347d28de43720a4d489e333cedd", "sha256:77d393e657ba946edfe70c2e4246b8a2ab8930848c5b2cbed2282daf5813adc4", "sha256:814a86a62e1330f8933702c2c067b325ee7d6e292d483f20d81bb21bf7bfd248", "sha256:55bc2281827c3db5a0a85c6e5d2ab8d8e6b10d015787ca9866052ac539a17704", "sha256:0e5cf62af54ff32783eba248ca90e982bcbde902bfaf685ecc63a2c2f4a6b345", "sha256:eae0cd3d6982f2a5accd35614a480757be8a0d18194498046a64ba413ad3c509", "sha256:a18eab827b26d89f2666ca686960ae911c259884ed7be769b7d9a4ec3ad026d0", "sha256:74b4bf275b3fb6c4c8e8dffeba5aaf8e1a51c03dbce4eceee74048c69e157d35", "sha256:bf052c0580f84942f1a1408cf9c5ea2cd8989b009cac4cc50f73c93306f12001", "sha256:7dd014342a751ae9cfb98c3723c1581adb68ef4a0db990091a070bd680cabcb1", "sha256:b03846055d7270629ce1336901a0036d75f3b252f2bbcc60d8e2311be2b1da0d", "sha256:c1956c9cf197bfbbff292a2811f9feb14412969eb0b988f76f5d3465e164d3f0", "sha256:823894ebf20d74656e4a8c73efe4c913b2b691536ca725f00e5ed90cf443328c", "sha256:4922a97ecabaf9e12d82c3268abe6e89d2995ee4ad7d2d7b0fe9c06168654e02", "sha256:058f569bbdd0f442813abcae86beae71877bd17755ad8289c2b623888479f5c7", "sha256:b9c06ba6da5b5960c622f22b3ea85a3c74612dc972fe8a9fe2b104762c2181ec", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb", "sha256:41a063f9f0085503b0a11f88a6bbf87abfd653c7afc2a10454797f935837473a", "sha256:bfcbe2012cf8960de07f54b517465555cc32b22955b518d5c4e8ff4831f253bb", "sha256:adb6cf5832b4c54bf62285122f79fcbc827113fc22a47f141517ad029732ada5", "sha256:4bd2f2b8170c046f51ebe132848030c52c6d886b2ad5fa2557f61a61d64e9021" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "canary", "percent": 5, "revision": 5, "healthy_windows": 2, "last_end": 50, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4", "window-5" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-6", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 5, "start": 50, "end": 60, "observations": [ { "customer_id": "user-1", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": true, "mature_at": 110, "artifact_id": "sha256:4b396659e15801195c7dc9d9125302088a31324149fdb6118a90f5d7d3b58c85" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": true, "mature_at": 110, "artifact_id": "sha256:23912d3d85d45ee232c960873d6019603ee1f3d9bc908d0752592db350bd4e84" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": true, "mature_at": 110, "artifact_id": "sha256:502269a9b952d263b33bcb986213f6d8b1d14c96de0c81c71ca166a8a993e957" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "baseline_pass": true, "candidate_pass": false, "hard_violation": true, "mature_at": 110, "artifact_id": "sha256:5591c07d036bde8ad23f45acf2d0ab4f82dce7d80c5abeeeeebfeac49046496b" } ] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "rolled_back", "percent": 0, "revision": 6, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 50, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4", "window-5" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "hard_violation", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": false, "served_candidate": 4, "served_baseline": 36, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06779201794415712, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057416968047618866, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-a", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-a", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-a" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-a", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-a" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-a", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-a", 4000, "USD", null, "refund:order-a" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06145797669887543, "wrong_order_commits": 1, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060333055444061756, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-a", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-a", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-a" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-a", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-a" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-a", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-a", 4000, "USD", null, "refund:order-a" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06412499351426959, "wrong_order_commits": 1, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05441601388156414, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05425000563263893, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05429098382592201, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05287496605888009, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0754169886931777, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06433302769437432, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05416700150817633, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05420803790912032, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.057958008255809546, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06049999501556158, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05283299833536148, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06495800334960222, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06270798621699214, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054750009439885616, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05604198668152094, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06333400961011648, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-a", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-a", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-a" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-a", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-a" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-a", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-a", 4000, "USD", null, "refund:order-a" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.07050001295283437, "wrong_order_commits": 1, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06366701563820243, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05412503378465772, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06125000072643161, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05237502045929432, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05929102189838886, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05570898065343499, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05370797589421272, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06324995774775743, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05299999611452222, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05616701673716307, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05170796066522598, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06616598693653941, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05983299342915416, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05929096369072795, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.059959013015031815, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.053292023949325085, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "candidate", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05970901111140847, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "fault-injected-candidate", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-a", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-a", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-a" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "order_id": "order-a" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-a", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-a" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-a", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-a" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-a", 4000, "USD", null, "refund:order-a" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06091699469834566, "wrong_order_commits": 1, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": false, "passed": false, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05487498128786683, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052499992307275534, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06074999691918492, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-6-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05441700341179967, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "wrong_order" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:f61a071e7ae7148c7a089bae5d9851c0a7ce014a92c50e4e64d710c8ec9fb6dc", "sha256:4b396659e15801195c7dc9d9125302088a31324149fdb6118a90f5d7d3b58c85", "sha256:23912d3d85d45ee232c960873d6019603ee1f3d9bc908d0752592db350bd4e84", "sha256:8add6062dc39c4208427b3a45ca9bd9568bf7fa22e6ad81c170d1dac5d755bf1", "sha256:20fa248f906d2c4f0b6ee4e51a571f0f9beefc53b938fa72998be9979614fecc", "sha256:0869702bb54cb3af924569fd71e8f74f51c8026f0462021fbec146b65ddc54dd", "sha256:4a7e838201d227d9a3a6daeff1aa9658492a19858b0a24e82a21ca092b91546e", "sha256:526d26689ef756a7393b204282d312a4c0922c122cf005e2783186e495403a22", "sha256:9de1f85d4ad0e077b5703e3ecb8aa4e2431993dcf830a2243ffb67a32dab49f2", "sha256:f5b5ee3caaab37b1a58687a2b7336d6cfb4367181e3d5acda70e28eb2f00d909", "sha256:bb39464abf3cbc58bb1ecf3853c84d672e961c6341991dd994098fdb8591fe33", "sha256:fd9957585c2588a3b9fb8471fbc147192fbd611a0ab348500a498c20cd2f701e", "sha256:2190f962dbf665bb95e33e33a395ddeb577ce3783e7c1de33e345ba9ba0dfe4c", "sha256:df077e10236c82c59755622e368fe9b099bb6ea62db39ccbaa0c40b5855ef044", "sha256:772fcd8856ddef592dd9c5250806edf0fd81e113fe70ac7c32f03a5999601b1e", "sha256:e5273ec38a452750464819941fb88ae46aa74ef5fd5e473d6a1eeb2836f9c838", "sha256:0a05f28c29c170eb51f29b295d31e2f8b1915a9f115f3219c4c30a52fdca2082", "sha256:7c2980366a8cf9ab6f547b816490479fee7fc1a12eeaf57890d663cf2d306c33", "sha256:502269a9b952d263b33bcb986213f6d8b1d14c96de0c81c71ca166a8a993e957", "sha256:34ead16c1ff95735f758880f6d1a5d8678616a9ca29e4e7485bee7973e0e6d1b", "sha256:fc1e9ea95d8e83201d8d4e8db00e1c312df598dd6a9100ad4a804c5f1fff4560", "sha256:05c4262380714109831c8f0184e67293cdac57676d008f712774953e8cc5284b", "sha256:108566e19ff867a228b0149a1d78165efd6e07b269b84c9bc9bfbd729c4215c5", "sha256:e8f72bc499acd1a68f02fb2c1613aef7f85c3937c14fff74e9541f22e144d01e", "sha256:c84da6ce56252c4bcbe14444697823ce96c08fd2d1152f50c41c810916d72c97", "sha256:61ce182a91baa327607bc1c6d64c46772f7e57d8b7a0beb1a62a6a4d6dd81d39", "sha256:7d0740be8cd69bfd74c1b8f84c8528fd9adb7c4f4229d6d17b2cafc441b99436", "sha256:979510413f6589464fa09330cf84624d569b02341b575775da9ca994cf72c0b5", "sha256:f12a1ca957cb5884573a36c2102fda3127aa7e27ae0f1bf07c776460271346d8", "sha256:ed6810415ca32023511712ce44b7b2b1f7028a35ba016823219d7f5501c6e99e", "sha256:e65159c2086c06bc3d75915298cb4478a00ee64839d3dd4739e4b7929c603cb1", "sha256:2dd394cd616bba52e3440657564a7426769ffaa1dfdf9897647945f87ffe7eec", "sha256:a14ee9053942cbbb0c3fdd4fb50edc47faa464755075d1622c2b61773bdf42ca", "sha256:1b46e86d54218985109064531f621a9e1aede4d451aa72f9062054816d6aff7c", "sha256:e5c3c9e24199de54654e1fbefdb38fe2577ae7638671f2f5c6db0a936e010033", "sha256:5591c07d036bde8ad23f45acf2d0ab4f82dce7d80c5abeeeeebfeac49046496b", "sha256:c376c97ac696e358a58ab7d41a2d601ddc205857324a7d7193f4ad0805b81bf2", "sha256:c0293f699e286fe26e19b6059c3f0adf00396056249847a9bda34350b0bd997a", "sha256:390cdaeb2e9abfd0463ee32d6be13af57896f6ced48bfe1e85473f928ca4632f", "sha256:e6163be07224bc09281fd6b4ab47507ee1a00fa2b05c667b205f84ccdc123515" ] }, { "before": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "rolled_back", "percent": 0, "revision": 6, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 50, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4", "window-5" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "window": { "window_id": "window-7", "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "exposure_revision": 6, "start": 60, "end": 70, "observations": [] }, "decision": { "state": { "candidate": "cx-simulation-v1", "baseline": "baseline-v1", "stage": "rolled_back", "percent": 0, "revision": 6, "healthy_windows": 0, "last_end": 50, "used_windows": [ "window-1", "window-2", "window-3", "window-4", "window-5" ], "used_artifacts": [ "sha256:ef53108bd316028af3dc032817b0220f30724faddf1a293a2af7e9bd1950aced", "sha256:299ae6e3bdb947d5bbfa9f79d74acea783f947c0eb3ee2d3bdd6ee9de00e13a7", "sha256:1d488010f840cfd39e007eba4d9d82bc782a143c601e5b442722192ec0f67aba", "sha256:d4376562fd53911f5389148441ad60f4a19c2fc70408a6acdf34bbe173636865", "sha256:06bbc09bad2b48054e6daf8cffaef0318dad2f3732b76e3e2faecd380ab59592", "sha256:7a928d354d041b569aabfd37d2d4b4fbfa5fab8da8245d6a98d25f91aedf80a3", "sha256:b564a77adf9d1177f55c6f72b8757c216d5d70562bc494dbeed0e632557be441", "sha256:13797afaf782261cd23009659768679425a409f658757cef91be90520acc8e64", "sha256:90d4efd3c6ce66e0b10eb936fadc71041b89fa14994f158e9b50e1640ccdb044", "sha256:43490901f06bf0ec2e8213ffa84efcf0d748b38f10ca65a68501138594b74461", "sha256:762f14c402f915c8843d0c4703e8fcea06f4cc3c420e08235edb253d03b9cae9", "sha256:5d517a45a53b92d4d1e20b44819c8a2762725250ddc3ba875898390e8a9dc4e7", "sha256:21e353b3aea9cb811f58249573b901b4e1353f73ada9674a940a6aeabf04fbe3", "sha256:1b44afed4c9a3dea80c73a58f55bfeb61a777250bc1b6c40ad9b04a60fcd4264", "sha256:739dd29dc8146b67e50d128914e5dfdc18e4607f8e88df60233d6d5ae1ba31cc", "sha256:d1a995d185980bb08833990d22859cbfc065f47983e197a88782aff26c8604d6", "sha256:a7f597109ab784db37c6476c7e794b0f092ebe74f82faf03c01a0805c824eef2", "sha256:ac891c9fcff034d6c3a4b4ba6bfd67ed171cc8d641540cf50b91ce298be0d269", "sha256:6fffb3423778d9b73cb2f927af51e4cc7664a82acab0404ee418164272818f9b", "sha256:0b073c1318338fe27757bc7375b2575b97669ee2bf0ae5c748c8c4e3235ba1d3", "sha256:b6efdd00bf3db2ebd51d663a1796bccbebe6ee8614079c8720819ba1cfe627f6", "sha256:b8e8d162a23739a5ff28fa5ddcbd48a99fd1555e26ad26cce5306571008a182e", "sha256:453ebc30cca07ccce82f4f4c0add1dc52aa0748ec1b4f93440ca2b1ccc58ca35", "sha256:3a47b6b629917b0f8fccfa6e260080c800ac7fc9b33cfd929607e1b0ebee0bb7", "sha256:af7c97526a8b16e5d1b9fa99886e449d1afad8d687e4c7dff27953e816f2bfd4", "sha256:048f9e5b910cffba4af66512d0246b5c65a36d8b75390a19f8df226cbebb9efb", "sha256:ae1e592a64d93ec078cf87df5a428745238d331bef69e17014c0553eab3c89a7", "sha256:393d0408ee814168f546db0ea7a90c4e468f4c8e1e305299b1f7554e7bf897f2", "sha256:8961507f8048109d490ca304c9095a2f6e752e270d7d08405db843ba6acb7914", "sha256:d1fa952c48a97c084b3c433965bd4b27a882984ab6b8de58b8d8885c38826e1a", "sha256:75c12085dc32384cc8795d8120a27d19894a1b62d58e326d00edd8054bcf88ed", "sha256:56f118d97313efddfdb9ffdd5780ae30891a203163035c5365b0606a0e1e4ebe", "sha256:e3038e7d9daeae957eb9c7e23471c4fb9aa112a4d17a1b9ff08be4b8a3113ee6", "sha256:655e41a89087ce1062c04711ddc6964149f93081c1549d7fe5101f637cfc288d", "sha256:ac962d78d19e509093608bfdaa670685c7c9db2e2c77cdfbc0850ffbb1dc840a", "sha256:6e20674f944e9a290c9946efe86722d11bb577a5225008d0d93da42f1bc0e118", "sha256:b32123369dd3f63913fc7fe42d560c0a7d0024f8527470f2e1cdf3703758ecc6", "sha256:2d7f215addb1fe479e011997c4828d38dc76211a545bd53ced844d0ededd7da0", "sha256:b436042b27aa55b51f2e516451ff82c2b52fcfa0cf8004cd872f1e214b539de1", "sha256:33fff21b3c5d39ad07fa477461f328a642da857420f518d3cbcf53cc70131c60", "sha256:9951ac1f29088eae814704ff80e6d812b155ee215ea6ee02522284f22d2b1bd0", "sha256:451d5d40f964a0b8bc5bf381453a37b89b58e48e51eef171c1b90f82c263b005", "sha256:dcdaac30e38d9b4f6a9c1c56e86117d0a3050dfd6c69dc3fe029d9d498cf69fe", "sha256:48951ea4ff89891a360262487f5525822b9ad94e046bef90a66c12206f3cf4b7", "sha256:c6d560d13b4b1c42724b26c214cb5bdb81663df179032fd826cd41e5d451c297", "sha256:65b14852798f123d4db0ea522253998661b435e8a81d9b6092f20a9d0c869547", "sha256:9447b332cf111de96bb8d99775d7978602eea60b3f6c130cb5fa87ee0322176d", "sha256:d298e1ac9a3de6ced12f4a24460d569853a8788fb1c3c0fbfeb1d537b14fbe7f", "sha256:ff1990277490e0c48aaf236492c34238f98c7a1b1e95f0a9a61cae8d7047c83c", "sha256:5a87a8dbeb5bc6996c95dbc45bbf463ad6633d1ab1bfdf2bd29493c958e57dd1", "sha256:c791aaa51edbccfcc9b222bcc10fa04c3b9231da685808eaca3e6a6e715214a8", "sha256:e69749c4370aa2aaddcdbeadf75ea541429b27c52f8f3e3cedb3922cdbac9791", "sha256:40ae8c02082e663aa322a255ebbcbc23065b1149dcb4b08ec479b90d54a74d20", "sha256:cd797b063550951c2af550f2580aa3e08d90114daf87d3d6170e3f96af614ebd", "sha256:f7b2cdb3ab0a43a278a92aa86a248a20706062e76095f4c1bbfb0ea617235859", "sha256:8068c255a312f34624eeace757a6aaeb36cb3347967dc1f0fed367a2b82422d7", "sha256:fd1cb1fccc39aea05f3384026c169df4bf3d08c592f5d24255c01fa54b26fc91", "sha256:719ef2488a035d56d3d074756076efaf7a7393bae9bcdcc501adf7cbd6498d5e", "sha256:489b3ad8a55578814bed62affb20849837bc1223212d93768de81f958aa45369", "sha256:61344cb6ec9a906ebd7ec34d77f7a6af3b256e7669567c3c9af8e2363130b2fe", "sha256:1745506dd419f33f9b67b76aa5de561fb1c64b7063234ac3b91ff3fdecaf566f", "sha256:5734160e98b6504b14f009c873b18b162c7bd309ea206bd074ad98aa834964cf", "sha256:6df3f3bf933cb6abda8b3b63c777d917440026ebd050862801aee8ba7f5ed325", "sha256:848f8cc1ed3d7dffde5f073a18ff2a3af568e8c0475ef7a54b00d898c3462fb7", "sha256:8f224d46aad9961198079700012c6e46c2437491763e95d844f2c172deaf36eb" ], "pending_window": null, "expires_at": 120 }, "reason": "rollback_latched", "deployment_authorized": false }, "resume_requested": true, "served_candidate": 0, "served_baseline": 40, "artifacts": [ { "customer_id": "user-0", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-0", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-0" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-0", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-0", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-0", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-0" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-0", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06549997488036752, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-1", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-1", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-1" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-1", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-1", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-1", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-1" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-1", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.08025002898648381, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-2", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-2", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-2" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-2", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-2", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-2", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-2" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-2", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05974998930469155, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-3", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-3", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-3" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-3", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-3", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-3", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-3" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-3", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06104097701609135, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-4", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-4", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-4" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-4", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-4", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-4", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-4" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-4", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06104202475398779, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-5", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-5", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-5" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-5", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-5", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-5", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-5" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-5", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.060624966863542795, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-6", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-6", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-6" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-6", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-6", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-6", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-6" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-6", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05687499651685357, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-7", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-7", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-7" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-7", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-7", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-7", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-7" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-7", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.059582991525530815, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-8", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-8", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-8" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-8", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-8", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-8", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-8" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-8", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05425000563263893, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-9", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-9", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-9" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-9", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-9", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-9", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-9" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-9", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05670799873769283, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-10", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-10", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-10" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-10", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-10", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-10", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-10" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-10", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06433401722460985, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-11", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-11", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-11" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-11", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-11", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-11", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-11" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-11", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.056917022448033094, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-12", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-12", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-12" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-12", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-12", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-12", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-12" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-12", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05416700150817633, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-13", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-13", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-13" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-13", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-13", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-13", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-13" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-13", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06799999391660094, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-14", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-14", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-14" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-14", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-14", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-14", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-14" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-14", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366600817069411, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-15", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-15", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-15" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-15", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-15", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-15", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-15" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-15", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.055374985095113516, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-16", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-16", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-16" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-16", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-16", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-16", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-16" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-16", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.051666051149368286, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-17", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-17", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-17" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-17", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-17", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-17", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-17" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-17", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05124998278915882, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-18", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-18", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-18" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-18", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-18", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-18", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-18" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-18", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05316699389368296, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-19", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-19", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-19" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-19", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-19", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-19", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-19" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-19", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052292016334831715, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-20", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-20", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-20" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-20", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-20", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-20", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-20" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-20", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05716702435165644, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-21", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-21", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-21" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-21", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-21", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-21", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-21" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-21", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.051458016969263554, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-22", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-22", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-22" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-22", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-22", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-22", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-22" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-22", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05329097621142864, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-23", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-23", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-23" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-23", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-23", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-23", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-23" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-23", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05045899888500571, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-24", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-24", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-24" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-24", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-24", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-24", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-24" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-24", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05179201252758503, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-25", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-25", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-25" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-25", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-25", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-25", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-25" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-25", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.2618750440888107, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-26", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-26", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-26" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-26", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-26", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-26", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-26" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-26", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.054374977480620146, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-27", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-27", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-27" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-27", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-27", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-27", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-27" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-27", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05608296487480402, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-28", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-28", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-28" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-28", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-28", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-28", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-28" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-28", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05400000372901559, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-29", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-29", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-29" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-29", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-29", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-29", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-29" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-29", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366699770092964, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-30", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-30", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-30" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-30", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-30", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-30", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-30" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-30", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0551670091226697, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-31", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-31", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-31" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-31", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-31", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-31", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-31" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-31", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.052709016017615795, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-32", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-32", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-32" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-32", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-32", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-32", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-32" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-32", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06416701944544911, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-33", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-33", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-33" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-33", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-33", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-33", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-33" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-33", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.0512909609824419, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-34", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-34", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-34" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-34", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-34", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-34", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-34" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-34", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05158298881724477, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-35", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-35", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-35" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-35", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-35", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-35", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-35" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-35", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05320797208696604, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-36", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-36", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-36" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-36", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-36", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-36", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-36" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-36", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05416700150817633, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-37", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-37", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-37" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-37", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-37", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-37", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-37" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-37", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.06695796037092805, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-38", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-38", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-38" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-38", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-38", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-38", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-38" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-38", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05366600817069411, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" }, { "customer_id": "user-39", "served": "baseline", "baseline": { "case": { "case_id": "window-7-user-39", "request": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true } ], "expected_order_id": "order-b", "clarification_reply": null, "required_clarifications": 0 }, "agent": "descriptive-control", "reverse": false, "agent_input": { "utterance": "Refund the blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02.", "customer_id": "user-39" }, "orders": [ { "order": { "order_id": "order-a", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-b", "customer_id": "user-39", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": true, "verified_customer_id": "user-39", "verified_order_id": "order-b", "policy_consulted": true, "policy_order_id": "order-b", "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [ "refund:order-b" ], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 1 }, "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "tool": "verify_identity", "status": "verified", "details": { "customer_id": "user-39", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 2, "tool": "get_order", "status": "success", "details": { "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR", "order_id": "order-b" } }, { "sequence": 3, "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "status": "success", "details": { "approval_threshold_cents": 10000, "eligible": true } }, { "sequence": 4, "tool": "issue_refund", "status": "committed", "details": { "approval_granted": false, "eligible": true, "idempotency_key": "refund:order-b", "identity_verified": true, "policy_consulted": true } } ] }, { "order": { "order_id": "order-c", "customer_id": "customer-other", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02", "amount_cents": 4000, "currency": "USD", "eligible": true }, "state": { "identity_verified": false, "verified_customer_id": null, "verified_order_id": null, "policy_consulted": false, "policy_order_id": null, "approval_granted": false, "approval_id": null, "approval_order_id": null, "approved_amount_cents": null, "approved_currency": null, "refund_idempotency_keys": [], "timeout_delivered": false, "refund_transaction_count": 0 }, "events": [] } ], "tool_events": [ { "tool": "list_orders", "arguments": [ "user-39" ], "result": [ { "order_id": "order-a", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-01" }, { "order_id": "order-b", "description": "blue backpack bought on 2026-08-02" } ] }, { "tool": "verify_identity", "arguments": [ "user-39", "order-b" ], "result": true }, { "tool": "get_order", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "order_id": "order-b", "amount_cents": 4500, "currency": "EUR" } }, { "tool": "consult_refund_policy", "arguments": [ "order-b" ], "result": { "eligible": true, "approval_threshold_cents": 10000 } }, { "tool": "issue_refund", "arguments": [ "order-b", 4500, "EUR", null, "refund:order-b" ], "result": { "status": "committed" } } ], "output": { "message": "Your refund has been confirmed.", "claimed_outcome": "refunded", "runtime_evidence": null, "transaction_status_claim": "committed", "settlement_status_claim": "not_claimed", "arrival_commitment_days": null, "message_template_id": "refund_committed_v1", "escalation_reason": null }, "execution_error": null, "elapsed_ms": 0.05924998549744487, "wrong_order_commits": 0, "unnecessary_clarifications": 0, "missing_clarifications": 0, "denied_attempts": 0, "premature_action_attempts": 0, "task_completed": true, "passed": true, "semantic_message_qualified": false, "authority": "lab_only" }, "candidate": null, "fault_intervention": "healthy" } ], "artifact_hashes": [ "sha256:e73b8517121bc5f0c26042e0f119a466a53af7541a6383ee236325a5aecfe6ce", "sha256:f9fcb02db77062935eb054cdb02ac8fa31880d0aeb9aba1bc1c82daae1576c3c", "sha256:261f898e58a1f380bbb5d46aa848212d25c0aaf1a4dfc2951ddac4567b970717", "sha256:8bf7aea04f807107224075d29740680235c27779bb3f1f100f6370edcfa69920", "sha256:7e7f5834b075e3a08f645198b79e6154eea1b6b2400565b7753f4af444ccefeb", "sha256:e95d5f70ce16075627324b62f83510cd0e5c000a61d0510f6e731eb5cc58e605", "sha256:93babf1ae832f13bb5d4458bbcf1920d10ae0877f05caa9ad5aa532cac10a2e1", "sha256:663afa285acb4157d2fb81e61d22cc98540e0ab589a56817da9b80949d9cc364", "sha256:bf364fa57d4b89f0992a18c1624558b5e3ff6aefb5a873bab7095bfa0d3e7f02", "sha256:37898928982d86302ffac5c665f67b6112171cdff7c1e3890f435d11f587fca0", "sha256:aef2fb1b72117793ad5e913ca16b88f9e9db362c8d1bca71f484e034f26071fe", "sha256:e7f1d2d1e846a2de01d55321502816b057d438f7fc9c5c4c323228ed1eb111b4", "sha256:b96e07b76c5d3ad76907047f7f00a59d59befe208a02a3a68b15f07cd11d2507", "sha256:d6a2d4cb2468bede33f7a126635500825a77197c559b0366e9dc9b815fb5e32f", "sha256:274838b0d5fa28fc6a0f483eeca3c9f82352e12b0b5df7045841de19c0439406", "sha256:713f8b444fc53c1be68eb475e9f6e9902f8b79b363c97446ec22abef2dbbb4e9", "sha256:beb71269f255d8dbaed6d76ea3121808cdbc0e47a2b482de04d864a691df13f1", "sha256:3ea417140b4d278b3865ea77a1613182396b58fdb2ec1c16002241c004318cb4", "sha256:4634d9920ba37e68e2ec250a2b52cf05c8af41b02f6a8907d8edddf5dce082bb", "sha256:7d6bdddc9ff72186a2b22666ab32be7e1682d8f6194c43fe61d55d7c3ab8b116", "sha256:434805b502b9e091a514cc8591089a44d90cc6a3a87b9a6997b0a3c103f4afb9", "sha256:cdef6a05c51c0f874cfe3c2f87c27c1c9990167587b1e836bdc5e60b6141de23", "sha256:dee821770bbaad91f9ca825a7fa7d339f1b0fb2fe928922faf9f76c4b786963a", "sha256:64751138de38afff5aa24dd6c1d529174b472ddd47c928926ea3fcda40c43166", "sha256:a1c2a95cd070f8ba0c489d4ae4afae08843f641af394a981190188d31f25fcb5", "sha256:42f77b624875bcf2ec2ac64e044f97638519bc9d5459ebf481afe454ccefa13c", "sha256:0cc6b8c2ed9d5fafcbc9a0ec5a2cafd771da48b4a3e46b806ec1046bc2318e97", "sha256:36b7b512a707dd82066bf1827174bd9b480003c5a2520d6005aeb4d0b972cb2a", "sha256:1c7d34e8472281518c0d6b9aeeb07825d37e8158490b2766b4f948663868da36", "sha256:852343ba62f0e9f598ee5558092e98d9942e0fff90868a0b0ddfe3091afca95f", "sha256:e5be44b56d71aa0b513de5e644e86dfd42fbff2e756c2e293616dcc0345e63d0", "sha256:d0b62dc63918afda1fbb837c3c3b7caca29de813279fe4a54c655091894c8272", "sha256:8c546cc8c314b270106449e481ab9ecdafbeec3476b2999ca02d70fd2d4c5906", "sha256:a484cecce7816df358b3d2c505c00ac6ba8e1fef14312a68286004c4b93c0bc9", "sha256:a050e977ea4285d7500388c37802b519a318598a68773abcf7e799e61ac819ea", "sha256:bd18bd4ff991bae8322480fb3a63f050756c509aee81b016960c4f1a704f5ce2", "sha256:fe67a1c8700376236ddd68b325a45fd61158e8920312ead45a6707e5c34c9608", "sha256:6c9c34ff41f1f21848a38d00dec94e3f4c028ac53c2fcf2d30c14a37c54621b3", "sha256:b8b7492eac625071ca95c1b10af5805919fc72abc63c820f8ebf11f4de131874", "sha256:90353f681fc20641769a22da4a2cdef52ad39b8325459dedf0bd1d4d665ce99e" ] } ], "source_hashes": { "exposure_study.py": "sha256:99d0cb0dadb52c5c4d2657bdede96dd3ccf0111ef3becc2ab6b25271b690f69b", "exposure_control.py": "sha256:352e1fe3dff02bd53b156af1d8125ded89bf17277762ed29d7e9701a5012dcb8", "order_resolution.py": "sha256:2ca70c8acaf3c9bb0b308cbc4ec7642b26135b9d7ef3b58d77f69c515698e04e", "world.py": "sha256:3f23837ad8cebff65932a1f9c37128ce3557f669c814a379d5800ef96a87a3cd", "agents.py": "sha256:5f351698eed35d16f278d485dc8f5fb6fec2af76cea43480e1cd0f92b0300d92" } }